If you run a shop, a hardware store, a pharmacy, an M-Pesa agency or a wines and spirits store, you've probably asked yourself: should I put in CCTV or an alarm? They do different jobs. Here's a plain comparison to help you decide where to start.
What CCTV does well
- Deters theft. Visible cameras make shoplifters, dishonest staff and would-be burglars think twice.
- Catches theft by staff and customers. This is where most shops actually lose money: at the till and in the store, during the day.
- Gives evidence. Clear footage helps police, insurers and you settle disputes about cash, stock and deliveries.
- Lets you watch from anywhere. Check the shop from home or another branch on your phone.
Where CCTV falls short
Cameras record a break-in, but on their own they don't stop it. If nobody is watching at 2 a.m., you find out in the morning. Some systems send motion alerts to your phone, but you still need someone to respond.
What an alarm does well
- Reacts at once. The moment a door opens or someone moves inside, the siren goes off and your phone gets an alert.
- Scares intruders off before they reach the stock or the cash.
- Panic buttons let the cashier raise the alarm during a robbery.
- Can trigger a response. Neighbours, your guard or your security company know something is wrong now, not tomorrow.
Where an alarm falls short
An alarm does nothing about daytime theft by staff or customers, and it gives no record of who did what. False alarms also need managing, or people stop paying attention.
Side by side
| CCTV | Alarm | |
|---|---|---|
| Stops a night break-in in progress | Partly (with motion alerts) | Yes |
| Catches staff and customer theft | Yes | No |
| Evidence for police and insurers | Yes | No |
| Panic button during robbery | No | Yes |
| Watch from your phone | Yes | Alerts only |
| Works in a blackout | With backup power | Yes (built-in battery) |
So which first?
It depends on where your shop is losing, or could lose, money:
- If stock or cash goes missing during the day, start with CCTV on the till, the entrance and the store.
- If your worry is night break-ins, start with an alarm with door contacts, motion sensors and a loud outdoor siren, plus a strong door and padlock.
- If you handle a lot of cash (agency, wines and spirits, pharmacy), add a panic button early.
For most shops, the best protection is both together. When the alarm goes off at night, you open the camera app and see exactly what is happening before you call for help.
Don't forget the basics
- Lighting. A lit shop front and back alley put off intruders and help cameras. Solar floodlights keep working in blackouts.
- Backup power. Cameras without a UPS or solar go blind when KPLC goes off, which is exactly when thieves strike.
- Camera placement. At least one camera at face height by the door, so footage can identify people.
- Perimeter. For shops in a compound, an electric fence and razor wire stop intruders before they reach the building.
Get advice for your shop
Every shop is different. We'll visit, look at how your shop is laid out and where the risks are, and recommend what to install first, so your money goes where it protects you most. The survey is free.
